Skip to main content
Category

Property Settlement Dispute

Assessed in Family Law Matters - Family Lawyers Sydney, Canberra & Perth

How are Contributions Assessed in Family Law Matters in 2022

By Family Law, Divorce, Family Law Disputes, Property Settlement, Property Settlement Dispute

In the sad event that marriage or de facto relationship comes to an end, one of the most contentious areas when it comes to the disentangling of two lives is the property settlement.

In particular, the issue of contributions by each party to the relationship can become a common sticking point in any division of assets and liabilities. Contributions can consist of both financial and non-financial inputs into the former union.

There is no set formula for assessing these contributions – each case must be assessed on its unique circumstances in order to achieve a just and equitable division of property between the parties.

This article provides some more detail on how contributions in a relationship are assessed by a court but if you are at the stage where a property settlement is required in order to properly end a former relationship, contact family law experts Mediations Australia as soon as possible.

Thinking about separation or divorce?

Why not take the guess work out of it. Book a free consultation with a family law expert.

More detail on contributions

As we’ve mentioned, contributions considered in an asset pool as part of a property settlement can be both financial and non-financial.

Financial contributions: In a relationship, these may be direct or indirect in the acquisition, conservation or improvement of any property of the parties. Financial contributions before, during and after the marriage or relationship may be considered.

One party may have property when they enter the relationship, for example. Whether this property becomes part of the asset pool to be divided in a property settlement will depend on how the property is used during the relationship and what contributions to the property the other party makes.

During the marriage, an inheritance received by one spouse, for example, will generally be considered part of the asset pool. As will career assets such as income, superannuation, long-service leave or a redundancy payment, as well as shareholdings.

In relation to property acquired after a separation, the interest of the ex-partner who owns the property is balanced against the other partner’s contribution to it before deciding whether it is added to the asset pool. Another method of assessment takes a broader approach and looks at all contributions made by the ex-partner (the one who doesn’t own the property) to common matters between the parties.

Under section 79(4)(a) of the Family Law Act 1975, the court must assess both direct and indirect financial contributions. An example of a direct contribution is a lump sum paid against a mortgage, while an example of an indirect contribution is the use of earnings to meet household expenses. The court often deals with the situation where one party to the relationship pays the mortgage and the other meets household expenses from their earnings, complicating the assessment of how much each party contributed to the acquisition, conservation or improvement of the property.

Non-financial contributions: Examples of these contributions include where one party to the relationship has improved the family home by using their own labour (renovating, painting, gardening, landscaping, for e.g.), as well as their contributions as a parent and a homemaker.

These contributions have come to be seen as no less important than financial contributions in family property settlements. Evidence of these contributions will be assessed by the court and given a percentage value, which is then added to the overall contribution that the court believes each party made to the relationship.

Need some information that relates to your circumstance?

Why not book a free appointment now with a family law expert.

How is this information used?

The assessment of contributions to the former relationship is one question in a number the court asks to determine a property settlement.

The court first determines the assets and liabilities of the parties to the relationship to form an asset pool for division; assesses the contributions of each party; assesses the ‘future needs’ of each party, and finally asks whether the proposed division of property and assets is ‘just and equitable’.

It’s important to note that when assessing contributions, the length of a relationship can be a significant factor. Where a couple were together for five years or more, the court will take a more holistic view of how assets from the relationship were acquired and maintained – more recent contributions may be allocated greater weight than older or initial ones due to the passing of time ‘blending’ an ex-couple’s interests.

In relationships of shorter duration, a contribution is more likely to be assessed on a case-by-case basis.

Seeking expert advice

Reaching a property settlement when a relationship ends is a stressful experience and understanding what you may be entitled to can be confusing.

We can help give you a better picture of what is entitled to ask for in a property settlement, in particular by assisting you to understand the value of your contributions to the relationship. Talk to us today at Mediations Australia.

What Should You Do Now?

At Mediations Australia, we have a team of family lawyers and mediators who can assist you in Sydney, Canberra, Perth, Adelaide, Melbourne and all other locations in Australia. We also do international family law matters.

Getting legal advice early is the most important thing to do.

Sadly people often wait too long to get legal advice. Take advantage of our FREE consultation with a family law expert.
property settlements Lawyers Australia

How Property Settlements Work

By Family Law, Mediation, Property Settlement, Property Settlement Dispute

Making a property settlement without the help of a court is possible.

In order to complete a property settlement without the help of the court system, there are a variety of tools accessible to you. You should, however, obtain legal advice from our team of Family Lawyers and Mediators at Mediations Australia to assist you with the preparation of your property settlement agreement due to the complicated nature of such an arrangement.

You will save both time and money if you are able to reach an agreement without having to have the Court intervene.  Additionally, you may be able to better your relationship with your former spouse, which may aid in the resolution of any future issues.

If you and your former spouse have reached an agreement on the terms of a property settlement, you should finalise the arrangement by filing an application with the court for a consent order or entering into a financial agreement.

Book a Free Consultation with a Family Law Expert.

Considering a property settlement? Find out where you stand sooner rather than later.

Agreements on financial matters

In that it specifies how property will be shared between the parties, a financial agreement is comparable to a contract. Those involved in a married or de facto relationship are permitted by the Family Law Act 1975 (Cth) to enter into a legally enforceable financial arrangement. It is possible to make a financial agreement either before to or during a relationship. These agreements are commonly referred to as prenuptial agreements.

If you decide to get into a financial arrangement, you must make certain that you fully comprehend the conditions of the agreement. Before entering into any arrangement, each party should get separate legal and financial advice from a qualified professional. If the formal criteria of the agreement are not satisfied, the agreement will be deemed illegitimate, and the court may order its termination. For more legal briefing in property law you can take the help of Strathpine Lawyers.

Orders of consent

It is possible to reach an agreement on a property settlement between you and your ex-partner by creating a formal agreement in the form of a consent order and then requesting permission from a court of competent jurisdiction. Similar to the way a contract works, when you sign the agreement, you are stating that you agree to the conditions laid forth in the document. This is similar to how a lease works. Once the order has been approved by the court, it becomes legally binding.

It is also possible to seek for a consent order without having to appear in court.

Considering a Binding Financial Agreement or Consent Orders?

Let us guide you through what is best suited for your circumstance. Book a free, initial consultation with a family law expert.

Property settlements imposed by the court.

You can file an application with the court to have a court order made on behalf of you and your former partner if you are unable to achieve an agreement outside of court. A court will only issue an order if it is fair and reasonable to modify the property interests of the parties involved in the case.

According to the Family Courts, a four-step method is used to evaluate how much each party is likely to get from the relationship asset pool in the event of a divorce.

In most cases, property settlement talks are done in percentage terms, with the percentages changing as the process goes through the four rounds of the procedure. If you are going through a divorce, this four-step procedure will help you decide what the courts would regard to be a “fair and equitable” allocation of your assets in the case of a divorce.

Consequently, let’s begin with the first step:

Can you tell me about the assets that you have in your asset pool?

Your asset pool, which is made of the following things, acts as the foundation for all property settlement agreements. It is important to understand how your asset pool works.

The value of money, whether it is held in joint names, in your own name, or on behalf of another person, such as a child;

Obligations – once again, your liabilities are included in the asset pool, regardless of whether the liability is held in your name or not; and, once again, your liabilities are included in the asset pool.

As a result of recent legislative changes, the status of non-vested superannuation in the context of a property settlement has altered significantly. Non-vested superannuation is now recognised as “property,” rather than as a retirement benefit.

It is the most basic and reliable technique of calculating your joint asset pool after a divorce is to go through the process of financial disclosure, in which both parties share financial paperwork. It is possible to provide documents in the form of bank statements, tax returns, and appraisals, among other things.

Disclosing information concerning your or your spouse’s property interests, as well as your or your spouse’s individual earnings, financial resources, and trust ties, are all acceptable forms of disclosure.

In accordance with the Family Law Rules of 2004, it is required to give a complete and candid disclosure of all relevant facts (Chapter 13). You or your legal advisor should be able to identify your spouse’s direct and indirect financial conditions as soon as you or your legal counsel gets the disclosure.

Need some information that relates to your circumstance?

Why not book a free appointment now with a family law expert.

How did you get your hands on it in the first place?

Another way of putting it, how did you add to your asset pool during the length of your marriage? A factor that will be taken into consideration by the court is whether you and your spouse have made financial or non-financial contributions to the purchase, improvement, and conservation of your property, as well as the welfare of your family. A property settlement is often viewed in the same manner as a monetary contribution made throughout the course of a relationship, and both financial and non-financial contributions might be given the same amount of respect.

This means that the majority of your financial contributions to your asset pool will come from your income and the way in which it was utilised during the length of the partnership. Your financial contributions, on the other hand, may include gifts or inheritances received during the course of the relationship, as well as cash donations made during the relationship. An enquiry must be carried out in order to ascertain how these monies were spent and whether or not they are still existing in your asset pool at the time of the discovery.

It is equally crucial to make non-financial contributions during the course of the relationship as it is to make money ones. Making contributions in a variety of ways is possible, including providing care for a kid or children, cooking and cleaning, and overseeing financial matters for the home. It is usual for one person to take on these obligations so that the other person may work and contribute financially to the family, despite the fact that non-financial contributions cannot be ascribed a monetary value inside your asset pool. Therefore, in a property settlement, non-financial contributions are accorded the same weight as monetary ones.

What are your hopes and aspirations for the foreseeable future?

A divorce will almost certainly result in one of the parties having more financial requirements in the future than will the other. There are a variety of elements that might impact your future demands, including your health, your age, who is responsible for primary care of a kid or children, and your income, among others. According to Section 75 (2) of the Family Law Act 1975, a full list of the reasons that the court must take into account while evaluating future obligations is set out in detail.

Consider the following two real-life scenarios:

Following the separation, there are two children under the age of twelve who will very certainly remain in the primary custody of their mother following the divorce. This will place the mother in a position of primary caretaker for her children, which may limit her capacity to work and provide a living for herself and her children. This will be taken into consideration by the court as a possible future requirement of the mother.

Book a Free Consultation with a Family Law Expert.

Considering a property settlement? Find out where you stand sooner rather than later.

The husband is a lawyer who works full-time and makes roughly $160,000 per year, while the wife is a nurse who works full-time and earns approximately $70,000 per year. Most likely, the court will come to the decision that the Wife’s income is the most valuable asset she may take from the marriage.

The court’s discretion will ultimately determine whether or not you have a future need and how that need should be met as part of your property settlement.

The allocation of resources is fair, according to question 4.

It is the legal phrase “just and equitable” that is used to characterise the scenario. In practical terms, and following the completion of stages 1 through 3, this means: The allocation of the asset pool, which includes obligations and superannuation, is equal in all respects. Is the asset pool distributed in an equal manner, to put it differently?

When it comes to divorce and child custody, what you or your spouse deems “fair” is not often what the court considers “just and equitable.” Many people believe that dividing your asset pool 50/50 is a fair distribution of your money. This is a frequent misconception. If you are getting married or entering into a civil partnership, the court has a responsibility to guarantee that the financial and non-financial contributions made by both parties are taken into consideration, as well as their future requirements in the framework of your marriage or civil partnership. Due to the fact that the court will take all of these elements into consideration in the context of your specific relationship, the court will make any necessary modifications, resulting in divisions such as 55/45 or 60/40, for example.

Although the 4-step procedure is rather straightforward, as is true of most things in family law, it is not without its flaws, and your final conclusion will be decided by the individual circumstances of your partnership. It is vital that you receive independent legal counsel as soon as possible after your divorce has been finalised in order to prevent being misled during the property settlement talks. When clients come to our office a few months or even years after their divorce, they often bring in what we call a “dogs breakfast,” which they have constructed because they did not obtain even the most basic legal guidance while they were still married to one other, we are sometimes surprised.

Before engaging in any property settlement talks, it is advised that you have at the very least a basic grasp of your claim after going through the 4-step procedure with your legal counsel. Following that, your legal adviser should be able to give you with choices for completing your property settlement in the most expedient and cost-effective manner possible.

What Should You Do Now?

At Mediations Australia, we have a team of family lawyers and mediators who can assist you in Sydney, Perth, Adelaide, Melbourne and all other locations in Australia. We also do international family law matters.

Getting legal advice early is the most important thing to do.

Sadly people often wait too long to get legal advice. Take advantage of our FREE consultation with a family law expert.
What Is Included in a Matrimonial Property Pool?

What Is Included in a Matrimonial Property Pool?

By Property Settlement Dispute

Coming to a property settlement that meets the satisfaction of both parties is often the hardest part of a divorce.

While it’s a necessary process so that you can both move on with your lives, working out the ‘pool’ of assets that need to be divided can be a complex process. Is it only the assets you bought together? What happens where you held an asset in your name only throughout the period of the relationship? What about any assets accrued after the relationship broke down?

We’ll attempt to answer some of these questions in this article but if you have similar questions as you face the unfortunate prospect of divorce, seek the advice and guidance of Mediations Australia. We will help clarify the issues for you so that you enter the property settlement process understanding which assets from the relationship are part of the negotiations.

Working out the property pool

Dividing assets in a family law property settlement is governed by the Family Law Act 1975 (‘the Act’). The law makes clear that assets can be considered part of the total property pool including assets held by both parties to the marriage as well as those held in either party’s name. The assets to be considered are those held at the time of the separation unless one of these assets was also used to create a new asset after the parties separated.

Typical assets assessed during property settlement as a result of separation and divorce include the home the ex-couple lived in, any investment properties either or both owned, cars, share portfolios or other investments, savings accounts, debts and superannuation.

Superannuation: Superannuation can be treated in different ways by the Family Court as part of a property settlement. The party who has contributed to – and stands to benefit from – the fund might be allowed to retain that benefit but the amount their ex-spouse may have been entitled to in a split of the fund is recognised by an increased share of other assets (such as sale proceeds from the former matrimonial home).

In other situations, one party’s super fund may be the subject of a splitting order where its value is divided between the ex-partners at an agreed percentage or a ‘flagging order’ where the non-member spouse can access a share of the fund once eligible.

Need some information that relates to superannuation?

Why not book a free appointment now with a family law expert.

Trusts: If one party to the marriage held assets within a family trust, the Court has wide discretion as to whether these should be included in the property pool. The exercise of this discretion will be assessed on a number of factors, including the level of effective control one party has over distributions from the trust.
The court will consider a range of other factors, too, including:

  • the terms of the trust;
  • the identity of the trustees and beneficiaries;
  • how assets within the trust were acquired and financed;
  • historical transactions and distributions from the trust;
  • income created from trust assets, and how this is distributed;
  • income distributed since the separation.

Inheritances: Where one party to the marriage inherits money or other assets as a beneficiary from an estate when they receive the inheritance will usually be a determining factor as to whether it will be considered as marital property. If the inheritance is received during the marriage and spent on assets or other things such as home renovations that are shared by the couple, it will likely be regarded as a contribution to the marriage.

An inheritance received during the break-up of a marriage, however, or after separation, may not be considered as part of the property settlement but could still be accounted for in working out the future needs of each party because it is a financial resource available to the beneficiary of the inheritance.

While the Court generally favours a ‘global’ approach in working out the matrimonial property pool – taking account of all assets held jointly and separately by the parties to the marriage – it can in some cases adopt an asset-by-asset or ‘two pool’ approach. This may happen where inheritance is received by one spouse late in the marriage, or after separation; where the marriage is brief, or; where one partner has a significant amount of superannuation and the other does not. The asset-by-asset approach necessarily increases the complexity and time involved in reaching a settlement, which makes it a less preferred method.

What factors does the court consider in dividing the property pool?

Under the Act, the Court must determine what is fair and reasonable to both parties given all of the circumstances. This assessment proceeds by first working out the value of the total assets, minus any outstanding liabilities. The Court then considers:

  • the direct financial contributions each party made to the marriage, such as wage and salary earnings;
  • any indirect financial contributions by each party, such as gifts and inheritances;
  • the non-financial contributions to the marriage, such as caring for children and homemaking, and;
  • future requirements in light of each party’s age, health, financial resources, care of children and ability to earn (including the effect of a property settlement order on each party’s earning capacity).

Considering a Property Settlement?

Find out where you stand. Book a free initial consultation with a family law expert.

Time limits and legal advice

Once a divorce is finalised the parties have 12 months in which to seek an order from the Court regarding property settlement, otherwise, they must seek the Court’s permission to bring an application.

You may, of course, reach an out-of-court agreement about the assets from the marriage with your ex-spouse via mediation or other means and have the Court make the agreement legally enforceable through consent orders.

Whichever course you prefer, a property settlement provides some finality and closure to the relationship, leading to the peace of mind to enter a new part of your life.

To reduce the time and stress involved in coming to a property settlement with your ex, consult with Mediations Australia and we will guide you to the best possible result in your circumstances.

Talk to us Family law Mediation today at Mediations Australia. We can connect you to the best mediator in most major cities in Australia including Canberra, Perth, Adelaide, Melbourne and etc.

Getting legal advice early is the most important thing to do.

Sadly people often wait too long to get legal advice. Take advantage of our FREE consultation with a family law expert.
What Do I Need to Disclose in My Property Settlement Dispute?

What Do I Need to Disclose in My Property Settlement Dispute?

By Property Settlement Dispute

The effective resolution of family law disputes mediation relating to property settlement relies upon transparency between you and your ex-partner to fully disclose relevant information to each other.

Typically “disclosure” is discussed in the context of financial matters, but it also can relate to mediation parenting matters as well.

The process of disclosing all relevant information to the other person is called, “discovery” and in circumstances where a person does not fully share the relevant information, it can have serious consequences.

Considering a Property Settlement?

Find out where you stand. Book a free initial consultation with a family law expert.

What Do I Need to Disclose in Financial Matters?

What needs to be disclosed in financial matters will vary from person to person, but usually, the following will be applicable in a majority of situations

  • Payslips from your employment
  • Any Centrelink statements
  • Tax Group certificates (typically for last 3 years)
  • Details of all assets, including any valuations of those assets
  • All Tax returns
  • All Bank statements (including credit car statements)
  • Superannuation statements
  • Details of interests in companies or trusts

Importantly disclosure also requires you and your ex-partner to disclose all information regarding any disposal of assets in the year prior to or the year following separation. Disposal in this context means, selling an asset, transferring ownership or gifting it to someone else. It follows that information regarding what was purchased with funds derived from the sale of an asset will also be required.

What If I Have More Questions?

If you wish to get more information relating to disclosure of discovery the Family Law Act 1975 and the regulations regarding the duty of disclosure in the Family Law Rules 2004 is the best place to start. More specifically, Chapter 13 of the Family Law Rules.

If you have any questions regarding disclosure and mediation, don’t hesitate to talk to one of our Perth, Melbourne, Sydney and Brisbane mediation teams.

Getting legal advice early is the most important thing to do.

Sadly people often wait too long to get legal advice. Take advantage of our FREE consultation with a family law expert.