The Different Ways to Resolve Family Law Disputes
There are now numerous ways to resolve property settlements mediation without having to go to court. For example, Australian courts make mediation a mandatory step in the litigation process. The reason for this is that judicial officers in family law jurisdictions have long argued that court intervention should only ever be the last resort and only for those matters with significant complexities.
What Are the Alternatives to Family Law Litigation
There are a number of ways that you and your ex-partner can resolve your family law disputes. Typically though, most people have been trained to believe that any type of dispute requires legal intervention. This is a mistake that leads people to be tied up in lengthy litigation that is both emotionally and financially draining.
Here are some of the ways that your dispute can be handled without litigation.
This form of dispute resolution is predicated on the basis that you and your ex-partner sign an agreement that you both agree to negotiate a settlement without going to court. This is an important distinction because other types of dispute resolution still allow a window of opportunity for court intervention if the negotiation fails.
In collaborative law, litigation has been removed from the range of possibilities. That’s not to say that you or your ex-partner can later elect to abandon the collaborative process and go to court, but importantly, the lawyers who represent you and your ex-partner in the process cannot. This characteristic is very important as in the event that you wish to abandon the process, you and your ex-partner will need to instruct a new lawyer, which goes without saying can be considerably expensive, not to mention the delays in bringing these lawyers up to speed.
Collaborative law is a very effective way of dealing with family law dispute mediation because of its unique features. Taking off the table the option of court intervention brings a significant degree of focus on you, your ex-partner and your lawyers to resolve the matter promptly. A collaborative law process usually takes up to 3 months to bring about resolution, as opposed to up to 3.5 years for the alternative, litigation.
Mediation is widely accepted as a very effective and cost-efficient way of resolving family law disputes and is mandated by courts, not only in family law, as a very early step in the litigation process.
Simply put, mediation is a structured negotiation process in which an independent person (the mediator) will assist you and your ex-partner identify and assess options for resolution and negotiate an agreement, following which it can become legally binding.
The key characteristics of mediation is that time is of the essence. Mediation will typically go for one day which brings a sense of urgency to resolve matters which can prove to be very effective.
Obviously, a mediation is substantially less expensive than the alternative of going to court. Mediation will cost between $2,500 and $5,000 depending upon the complexity as opposed to $125,000 upwards if your matter is complex. (Please note that research has found that the longer family law disputes linger the worse they get).
Basically, arbitration is the closest to court intervention out of all the alternative options to litigation. It has been explained metaphorically as choosing a private hospital, as opposed to a public hospital, where you choose your own specialists.
Arbitration allows you and your ex-partner to not only choose those that will assist and ultimately adjudicate on the issues in dispute, but you’re able to design the process.
Arbitrations typically run just like a trial would run in a family court. For example, written evidence is filed, followed by an oral examination of you and your ex-partner and your witnesses. Usually you and your ex-partner will be represented by barristers, and your instructing solicitor. Like a court, your Barrister will deliver their arguments to the arbitrator at the conclusion of the evidence and the complete proceedings are recorded in the event that you or your ex-partner’s lawyers require a transcript.
Importantly, arbitration is only available to property related disputes and not parenting or children’s matters.
The Family Law Act specifically deals with Arbitration in Sections 10L, 10M, 10N, and 10P.
Section 10L provides the following definition of Arbitration:
(1) Arbitration is a process (other than the judicial process) in which parties to a dispute present arguments and evidence to an arbitrator, who makes a determination to resolve the dispute.
Section 10P confirms the immunity of arbitrators:
An arbitrator has, in performing his or her functions as an arbitrator, the same protection and immunity as a Judge of the Family Court has in performing the functions of a Judge.
Further, Regulation 67S of the Family Law Regulations 1984 ensures that an Arbitrator’s award can be enforced as if it were an order:
A party to a registered award may apply for enforcement of the award as if the award were an order made under Part VIII of the Act.
Before hanging up a shingle proclaiming to be an Arbitrator, practitioners considering life as Brisbane’s next gun Arbitrator should read the Family Law Regulations 1984.
Specifically, Regulation 67B sets out the prescribed requirements for an arbitrator (also referred to in Section 10M of the Act):
For the definition of arbitrator in section 10M of the Act, a person meets the requirements for an arbitrator if:
(a) the person is a legal practitioner; and
(i) the person is accredited as a family law specialist by a State or Territory legal professional body; or
(ii) the person has practised as a legal practitioner for at least 5 years and at least 25% of the work done by the person in that time was in relation to family law matters; and
(c) the person has completed specialist arbitration training conducted by a tertiary institution or a professional association of arbitrators; and
(d) the person’s name is included in a list, kept by the Law Council of Australia or by a body nominated by the Law Council of Australia, of legal practitioners who are prepared to provide arbitration services under the Act.
How Do You Choose Which is Best For You?
Simply call Mediations Australia and we can discuss with you what may be the best dispute resolution process that suits your specific circumstance.